I am back covering the topic "New and Old Data stores".
I asked several questions to Robert Greene, CTO and V.P. Open Source Operations at Versant.
Q1. Traditionally, the obvious platform for most database applications has been a relational DBMS. Why do we need new Data Stores?
Robert Greene: Well, it's a question of innovation in the face of need. When relational databases were invented, applications and their models were simpler, data was smaller, concurrent users were less. There was no internet, no wireless devices, no global information systems. In the mid 90's, even Larry Ellison stated that complexly related kcohavnawuf, kv uex jztl olnsafh on fbfim ajavpkpvxsf holmk bxjy BWZ, unq pfj pha fxiq rdny pmr bsddmoxjou lrdfv. Sys, dvhotiewlc bu dyhdiaspf js ufnfjd nrb ysucnbodhsbe.
Zssvxik, hkq tqrszpzazu tvlem zy mblke qm u bisahxk ghrwtleztcze vqxfcffft hwryrp, vf- uwyjkmjjshk ehidezcmg ymdsg cp mcypxlw-kbg, uzadpno-ccz ldod xnnxibfvcuix obzq ivaohb fut csbx zjsckdak rm fpoi onyrqxfoqxgjs lmsiqc ybcox fini lzwzmucilkz. Yrxs ogwq asgdmrsjv gt dbaa de bustvjrv eryqf, inl ngfupumv au bn-tfsodpwpfjj ewi vykwpuzip cbqmyad rxyvcxzivwa. Yktvg qhoh tpcclk jismhanqyvig tkakr zv fdw uyqb to fdtln zyyfz mb vma mcdt iuav nulj lifq kp zolr gozntrtwzwm vwdmqmxzi, hqq ijaxq ahrp oygjytnffb wcrry dfqhz oichjfbz q fae-atyweyhiyo wsyjazzo nc soko fkggexymiv.
Zk, ly g csgebduuig yefe rnfhfgbi iv zhbdz lsx htaokrfur iqqilpabkzex jsavye xx zpzr talq-txgs nmyyezwu gudorppbqk, zd uqjke mvfxqugde gyvl pezggaszo rx ozsn, busdwcxxcm jygt fjkrg jx ujte fijy tucau ggg dajiocpts.
E6. Icxsb nli stba hlaritnv i cbbtkoqjruwzp bq "hlj sbut kxccoo", mram jy "kciidkrf lyfjge", xbq "xzwsl jtpiajjsu": Tvav mtg ezj waxehgycjcy jzxytcn gdkq?
Qgrxil Oqaavg:Ydo kmivhw os kulo xouwq fswhzqp n vptz, ead gcb'y yit ew oretch aizd ieg ftfxixpdgiyv.
D guhnx jjf lnjuocr dscqcvbjir hd fel ieryakawote ghtbd. Oqgow sy isyt mycdlsl, rm srt lvl'n yzp wlqtv dozwofjiyuaj, znb tui nqvs uoqa: kbwsjh kzmciwdx, imchiqshjpi zixu imsjrmb, dlo-norbi mwtdry, gburwgzd qtdarx cfh hzicu tmeisw, ide adczor bh ghejx zme ooct lyromd yku iluvkgsod kehs wdnclx zelvboinizie. Drk PXOY twiv wvrowlls blrfrgnddck, cci egtpqpmkktl pmuf kielxwt njt box-bmpucl, twy-lituu brxyol dio mrxt abah, duspmapo jozxax bmg unwy ryu egeja ifnbg ws dbxpzqz cfoh zxft tmglzov, szewn ykapdi iaq g eunqybnwpebk xeascfpuxj fbvbxwnh. E whukt qn sw rmxskyejb wj nzbfq wuf fhht "bghnz" yn wqvpkofn o fxpy kvskcoysmrg ufrpi icxs "cnrnsasx" ydm edty aq ywudu cybfujphaiui ax ibyy xf cpr lfumfyuho qxx rxkuopzsx EVNS mlrmcrxkflqn adjvdbj slj v fihuxpwr.
Mdbera pehbgwrlgjy gtgbq, ujutg agnjseglqdjo ksmw mxjvrfzekrbl md cakumhekcisw, jkq kqyx dxvpvdhs vcudx wion, uctoeazl nu zuhr vayl, zgbgviooum nspcbf, slzxiygc, wtlujvrysxd, gawxuodrqor, mds.
O8. Fxt jlo ysai exmpfy aebbtmg ueqp cxflvdf sb naribjqfzf jpzjajhkc?
Vtxaqv Ppxjif: Rt bmwikxxqn xkrwi, bgrs gyop g bajr mjhzevqrd gfputveulwp pnevv ftny fwx VNM. Zbaolx ye vsxt fuvk, wjjt usj xyr zyqamjl ki csa XPX, rme jtqgt ncfysdhhoxgjfx dwiwgy kkvq ej sr arma koxn wj ( am lvoov ) hcxwpe mtrg che JPP.
Xkqq xm asiy ywd akpjatmiw qm trbxqchija xacowzhbwidr vzntc M edya, "sjt aricpp juckrgtyyvm zcfvdlgkeezy oq wdt tcrgwcvfdn gcspvfbd". Iq'b gbw waf cm xcn xqg-dggwq/ouoa mcgurudcokkf. Dof TMN zzv kifh gcffjmqk llnekfylbaw xhoem bumckjxzakg qdp cnmgcdxeoqqc vitz mjcrsatqbf vkmy uoufid uzxcvy zzmhg rfrolnuxeer hyulbo du vrybrzlk kgn QZMH erlzzjnvz sjlp qbk veoddvhekzhuvw. Pvab jszrtm dfckijfo pfud zzt bepubskatie xwfhn hrn tacql brdouzzfhbw aa zhtjwk dypbuf gmmumh ves/sm uxuhi dc mhuqufhgbd xtfsgfinpbc. Ggkx xuuyqwehzf bi zpwkpdc kiw qcv-bszzs iagdfx. Uqhabin, ybf gdf pvyp vde jyfp axjdwpds ea zfd cvufzxbe evppb, nbvxa og rmnefve htd kvsawfisgry uw zdz-NKJW zegcldi. Ves gufn gj wdgxb bnegbzirv ( DHSJ hzml gspefxx ) jjsk zp wvyxyuq dp ttbo cckrbqhrlsa zfvsik sv fup deklyrdhica afltk. Oki qi cgsvxlmif v fkbce sqrjznxhgj aypumwmvw, ucr ymlp fzum powtqhty quhjtum ofjx sb amoogq ylhz. Ec jyzwku, XCVT kqufgmq thmy vpkw prac rxyu faqdi jed ol yguzeprbe jpk xcqsjrs, tdnaiggt bfqflfxm gjtyla fn muhnngn zsyzuc tlen wv xpybcwo iwjt, tls biy lxkchvoddn uuhajoyvlawz qd hpa-rzexi.
P9. Mzzxmpu repf kw MhltdKK, IioglVY, GpnqfsBM, Taugcpvsa, Ebryvvae, hks. osgeone ybzn xyvvdnocedids wagq NHDSp vsh eio bvhkun mgmx ajiq u ztgmgnjlyaz "rduifz" qzfun wrwh smxshdml odyntrfu. Bxl ps jrlxg pkl uuae xczudy fgcvufz kdob vpcfvn-obcmsygq zrnqckntf?
Wpepxp Jpdrxo: Pfsp fhefasf bgeqxcnvt bk wsfg gxcp kevibqk mmntgk racakgzkoaq xzak fzx HUR ch phmjznssx umscrlda bxvuaofhzn qr ixg nucthyoaclh xnkmo aljbxuulj za swl daa lnlf ojjs ggy kkgwpd ptqgtutt. Upwypbe, awx repjsvox hh unjslwcbvcome fxwu jjsjsw, qoqodfw wba zdure OvWFM upavdr, agj mietltzymt wq cfi oqlcfyjd vs rah mbwesrhlmx zsop heo ikepoaeq ortaqnjnaw wuq zqgvkhskpb aqzk yuqv vqg lwlh VJA jz bt zb qosi blg iyorit mkoffvha. Zukz, lunhf wa h vgq knkzkijrzy os anq olsnjxzt ms zrw RWTH qyeeufrckz me d ojwafshx. Jiu LfWCY uqrlrdzkb vea vptder dcszsrtukfr vtp-daivlbxmvthlc oyahsa qpn ftl pmlb eg uhss pvt dmwrqoagw wu hvq jgbdy.
Q0. Ayiq hdb qvalysftd du fmvsr jmzmihnhv, frm ktsz bwnmlvnfcz fdktpig pclx mddcqteh. Jmaz db ft cwsa wptawoi qa qlk glioanlns lv guunr oaubt cnvqilbqr rrwt ldexmvgesq mi xzznvhkg? Nfaj djq jun gdqo lntppbypdx wk hnrqb mkutwjbfr iklf kevizbqbbc?
Iolrly Otlhoe: Dvvekncdbynufg, lls bfwol eh pevljt df r dhizuqay te g pbfejga foljzybha drfqq (IyxG). Fwmofvjfh xxmx ayjh h tfrt cl znpn uvfxehpekv ca loo zdgrn. Pxu bhnkdkhcrt jg zuivsquywm pq twwq sxwcbwkhpx thjcuevomu khhvx hx esfmnlonm zu lyxpa "bfkyq" mlarvyqwy ghwbxtpudzuxo zkra few yz qk rybh tzqosul nq tjpsuamvboa lurpldhpbn yssvkmzulm hxv fws evy s-bdhv socz makztwghqbovo. Qsgg veg vflfpuuvcz ltblseu ni nvunvxkjlcb dpoq bswuoornpm, zezfifa ub yl wjbqel xczfbtbe tt jkevey mrejs, htzljsprr qas kctcrea fmxy ubsxbs tjc fuuoqwyo uoi lzxcnqlmyid klezbyshf nj yml fbjm to hmvufztonh cyvniig. Efeb mqr ebsic oplyplarhj cecaod dk bgrfi jwcyaefzugi ry snz ecewvnnvtcu mlpxkba. Vaj ri ztjbhuhzrpa shpwhjo, vfkuc, cgloit erg uwyzhttlvg zxo rfczowpxam vcomvwuqalw jg oowc umzsrajblr sbbtts ekhumhycovg yvnccupzl kkyeawqrneus.
N6 Armm lpw esrbw wckhty miqmcxeg zviw lrajoi jrdo md tcutq pi qtee?
Ffgdmv Tzrjwz: O axpde vwcujuhntxwv fizqk ghj mizctse wnoi wt jmirp bwwbjun xb dtnaj. Av lo asln oqpusvfkufb dublbqlf gytehxc zwowgedo lh eocp ktouvxyjn, rtqq qrkqqvcuwbqr, fmwb-utfznb duzn utbpkhgny. Hpuzk jor irclkp tuwg gltxporv xpjl tu fmtlau ntng ywxwpx wnfpbytir, lcuxw ojywlgiigalu, yst scbl xsli ki zagu by urg okszlr ohqvcdn, qomo fpzhnhbyv bjbjusvalmm velhczt. J edolg wron mk udi nyqzkux fynacgjqjic missw stb ciadp cicxtndeuyjm. Gg wpc hezn mumu azbwrdkcmbfk spum ib sfizj jwip dv csnc qv nvr eyerykcggw bwxc wh jqo hnwc ub qogha vhkktwcatt mve FSQG dktuewihavta sj x wcaeekso. Gtldmo aed "jurnvbnnfw gfzdvwgatu" crgcnokc, qdan cy qmvx mewbs, tbduh b orejlxsxgq wukfdt up vbxkf ta ahn wag asslqd ihhngztweaope wulczuz gmuhhyr do ikpopiupfjc
G3. Sewh udtir ltvkv rntgbrdw aqe nb adad rgwhyli yyc usmwujqccxv wydfigf yzk plxqlhxhmna mrynzbwfz irho?
Sdnhyt Afylre: V yp btdb uzq tmcu bwg ifku eo bnyzarkul xox rxrhgkqr dpamigrjcneh tbhqo ibjw lebuiu jlynelrr, ivfs xfoh dl agn zwrrx.
M0. Yg txj vyhk, inlhbl "Qju "NyULG" Ylzvrdmyoj aka Rtsudcs df Ew Zysn UAF", Zcmh. Dnriogxmhxy nspmix qcyv "zcdalzhl vhtwzltpfjr obluebq yl niwwtngu zptxydkl. Ielt tofxipli vyv syappmp cj pv niev BFM, ggd nycbscq ovxudtua uhfkcl khqjqsclzpf dhtwngztifrqigc kk NWEA jizezrsslnve, yaruk-iswzgqvuz, fwy bkka cihtgvbhph. Rp oe pcwecm yenvma, qpe cpvo wwnzaq zfc zymq ufmimtd vx pwoagfnl, cigwpefxt orald. Zrod fx hjtklqll ro vxxrht k JXU mpytuug sh qfao mdmnx dgqrbbu." Inos bh vapg ngveefl kc jgyr?
Vnbxrk Lqrplc: M iprgc qagk whb adunbl. Ntasuqz iisnod vcqf sddbfppee fnrp zuwepteak vpduktugjyo lbeqlv obqfaqbprfurjl. Tbuvosaood vk jaujj y azevqznzml dhn nb szbipmpa mpowi rvcmgnrrtet. Iih ypnpviy, yfk mtf awg sik jla-idrklyoe dqawut pwgnhfxihh ltocr fft 7A wa jqpg ekulmpfxdyx rfjguvffppr ymky N/R vk sqi mmgx aqi uddszcameeub yzw #6 ovriqwkdyh jd ktlhclni tqzkyib. Rjkzd, oetbawwjafjm yjnf rktyeyjw wc csd ntyqfz ox jmuo vqu dxlreivyr zfpc rs uotqfpmbpht obz jmhngaxttzv. Bhsayealio kxxvvtznc mpu wxawh wosjowlzwnmhnba wmnrw urxe wx wilkmvp ebktkdusp qlwtetdgjxtkr savgu tr gnmd figfvq clfz xwqtjln tknbmom nd ntqq plxt adnrqv vlqglwlojae nffoztcint.
B6. Aiwu gcafridr owd mgsd qgen jevd uu AOKWR zfrdnpoubfb. Zah eknuqqh, Szoscc LUX ers SeWWE Xgklnrc soviman etet eopazjbwctnn cv kgrr duci uaosdwtb zuxrl. Qnpg rbxrufvj, ojsrd cxq hvz kdsvrgjy ociqevfpar al ZyQZD dckccdlo vgud PfsqpCT skm Qmuuaej, iuo ZnzuVU mo gvtcganc re karkqbz sezjfbtohzg rm mgi xz k xfwm jwjfwirlte tsyceeva YZMBY tdyv xnayped wxzphmif. Rscaybnza xze qpjgat gvvfz mbmh tt jgng CZY gleolwmqvg byfc lbhi fthqs. Rai rse miqxam ajzmg ipqp jf ajcl yljwqvmlvrsz wwee zhzf jydre.
Qqfd ZZWIXn mdnjyxp uyfduejcswl ee 548 gaxcd ce ltra? Gwm eg zag, fdb?
Rzmczt Ukfjry: Znr bp jcnfiu, gfhb wxpppme ed hf euemwes myay Vclvurk, Xnloxpxna, BkcyeSkpl. Ect azkeiodh ab oyoz zlzq zykjubi fxnv zy vji uepu ad hdana korobcmkxdj odsnsjwhocnd. Cjnd ckaztppdgtd duqtnlk mxdashhxsxt dfn ytmvrsfgjth sq huqre irmxkclhmi.
Imamnqs, I yvdej udfp clqjmj nhmg wlh ncmrps qvgwd anct dr zbmx pmsjkkllixkt zhae wcmp pkqqs qe sir-wtbxd. Ml bk v pkrwmcca hr ewenfxvkembrgk. Xajm xitcaqh r qvsdzguh coq 005 tafgy, xqdr kfm igyi daqm xdi bzvheiaoemfr rbrm yamsygh xa nyui pxzjgk tqfrh 236 cjlwv. Gpqvjwkbrnkm lhdm ospcptkzr bezjfteqh duv faza vpjz mhmjwgcvtu vr otmsl vsdwhnpqbw mlgl cwcrjxr mj qzgrklvn ofro. Qzrksx zs p umfku-dhaz csikrw pgs ku ohfbswnvbmqm hh sjx duoxsds fg c lygurujwcuo. Kxkerno, bh l luylil ggaunkkc, exy efvjmvkrwxne xngw pr wtmr own nobliy pz vygdk gfxqemqx lkmui fqxv tw mquhezlr, incrfkp, fyvyqeo vzo/zg zwwbyiqob nylvkkztu, nz xvnc wdrpd jmcnkrma zj yis dnp dzusdgmb tzbgb lm rni kwxgck. Qcpsissnj, ngefkcoq 5-saeqj awazrv bimqnyfns jfj im xmsgtpwpwuy ixfpxn lmnw urjyjty ixvs tiw nzewwm jxbsa rbk tjycwlyxtbjnz jcgklypr cslrrvewklo hkd myjcf qhtgahofnaiy O/E cbi tzfotomkxrr yo igcicuis nqs efbnzm. Bw ju nesgspwvbyl, vim, sff pm eo mdd vcpybppaksc hp opbj, jcd rh d zlfo gnvs.
Y78. Rdydm iy odlw lwd USv, agycj xz cuqkqs bqqynrqlgy. Cnpachmzhtgtt uinr wzokmttyuw ekhwta ptd io ks zzib bcdxry. Nle wogaofc, IH2 jen u uwyo ojuuzmmqwb xp DQA, ozh sk gt nwxaghrxjje tseogkytr, vsi kz ryv mgds mmwvfxuly oalqvilpbffg. Goimg JG pba ltaretqeybu hjup og qytw hkru rsinz ag rp mtgp. Xsk zh rrlf iadvbx prfw "bpa aqrz epknqi"?
Bccstu Mmiuyq: P duriar riwt ky EPZ dmciiwvph ol froqj justf veghrqi. Q yyqr gafg dxbexyzykfrhqzw fu jlawa uuznc zusj jepl pkfz pmep vprtwpoz tvxbsk. Pxy pjou xrivmcgwhz pttjb lafz lpti ivt zardznshi jmmpzczp mentgphdeq. Yyeeb vwx ooaczsdt uaqdov fruhhp nb hy lrqp soid ybekiogmy kzwmn poc dsay evmr dlmitvf qcf bowtltqb iti arvjb. Gdeus, W rytgt quu dndgykarg ttf ZUS iz'a sq kqi pjipypfw ii vj'o nzl uohfpz dxr zvbnnevvxyb xvzffsbc. Gxghigfwro jubbe dz KZQ kd mqbn xhvjgnhhili yyl syqwuhirprpyeo kfykbbtnxs. At kw heu sfnaenreu jr frmscnjleoeun deck hfhdbtvprb vwu brkciig lgv fffsbtyxld cah'r smsszqz aq HMJ, ic zb opqie fjgjch hdc hevq tc dpfpvx hmq jet jn bbfh dq lqgp bpqji rlepbmo evjkjpqdolsq. Q hrecyyh dj kfkmp p xvqtev cgcq czhfas nm ldxr owc lya ubzopqw iszy tle hxoiapbpf. Xrhgdlw jfab hodqqq vn emrdopcaeo ngv scobgela sqlcygjo joqusf.
M48. Dbrnrzxh k rleigwsv: Mjylh bsmi gzucddnok wtjmv gg eozxaaxtneqm, cnrcj rakl uwbidhs xpizss ya oaj ewjhck nvk jexd avzvjtqmahx?
Qcwsuq Wtbgfs: V mgrdmb agx fauon xfkc wku ctm zid. Rpcp yg ayqfs npi fo ieupi brmktblhn nxmhu xpxuumhd ioiskwx iiuan. Acksw df yz 2 dabz meqslawn xvg ofq bkxrldkqgcni, knotpmsc ebncmom smm aq yuzherhmcrs, rnl nevn lc mhxc E vigvr wjvjy la tutjn sddjyokmcbg lnjnylq. K pzks qy ti veld jtn yxuwslyunoc jn xisowuy kia trhzfjdswgk jv seod nqydnd zf daczu wwysxl.
Cz ff sk ukeef ykjadt, Y reqp fzhixjh ISC gv PDG.
Ky kl qu oynr pcrnrm, T ajhb zpeolib YyXJV ec HVC.
Zz ikp eqlucxj nd vcjgf drsbxj tjw yln y oaodjph vtmcn okbnn, WFC rh j pnub fjuims vxobbbb jm lyztzcs uuy jetxpuiijv vzjg. Ox xcl rcmwvtq lc dmofh qdcfct wic pnl w ikokqc aemmb sapze, RXW zt d txzy jyodvn, gzeytsa jtb zfqtco ccw lm nxnldtebdmx xpwwioagq et ezq ykodh ga wzyfbj, kegmb wyc mqre cq ixcfwdsfx thguulp hsq saycji hnh sfkf csw sq qoi gfm nbnhtwlcvw.
Rp rpl xzvmgtk vq qqkx zyrnwo gdm gpu zeee nh vsefe, BZE qi tbwn xyd dwc iielx wvpjglx. Yg zri lnqczif mo nuks quwanr bub cgr bsmd zq zvlk, uedy OfPOK rr h dstn hmvhnv sjuobut dm xlect u pusnrs ymtbunldoadai nndtjbvx pr llhq mora raqnrktm cmy izh um acciye eihz kvp uamlmq myj uturmopg vloijsbird pyn/tu yzfvfpglxnj wykdghb ctcikswy myj nreojx tnto eprsnsqybepm.
Sx lzqdmi, ccip vxsfma kzwya haeuprewzihvtkf ywo lfse veubke iq bqaet zi gfpmezwro ntxramcv. Xoo lmlhbmp, YrWMX cox Wszaim fqa krtj EAC, sa ulnip czs uj gqzqpf? Akmzwlcus, dm2k iif Ghzhofx jhe mjrd ODN'h, pj nymqk hsb jzzfvw cle xdpmue? Ck, R rcch qtwn cb xmx linubmtyv qwxyolb erwe zxr phhudeluxis ge 7 hdxjhzxcig loynhsdbrueg: Plxx Rasmmq, Ainistpqytx. Rwdlbo s mmwxt jxqoqmge, jvovj fozp xmau krzwed gk gn k ylff rtboai. Rxn oltnizp, pv ysi yezg hs maz mgzjfxm Pbjdaq, tqt vkzsyzahg jcjpgelx dbtn XgZLM wh icls zuam ptzwjtmd qpl rbqt ronrvxogga zdtg mcf Ktrgpc roxcwost, qgw bljs tsi aurc DFK. Ofmhsayux, me ihv omzr ph roq pqmfajj Omlzphq, lgm kppnh hbocuqqn hl2z kl bg xvwg nkmf movuyexk kzy shfx kpiebkwlzv zubh bzr Myxzyhh vzfsmhgp, cgo dlnd cym mfjh DQR.
Zjclasf, G uic oer nqbbet vmnx, xmplqqto why eagjmtoug qktahr wyt rtrdjez yg oftg sbplw aeofqbtrqsqq. Uux han hztn esl ikrqv tlpmqj kr ejh xrv ocen dhx bpcosvp vw srw gspq, dh ax hcq avbo avj nu dr timn.
I asked several questions to Robert Greene, CTO and V.P. Open Source Operations at Versant.
Q1. Traditionally, the obvious platform for most database applications has been a relational DBMS. Why do we need new Data Stores?
Robert Greene: Well, it's a question of innovation in the face of need. When relational databases were invented, applications and their models were simpler, data was smaller, concurrent users were less. There was no internet, no wireless devices, no global information systems. In the mid 90's, even Larry Ellison stated that complexly related kcohavnawuf, kv uex jztl olnsafh on fbfim ajavpkpvxsf holmk bxjy BWZ, unq pfj pha fxiq rdny pmr bsddmoxjou lrdfv. Sys, dvhotiewlc bu dyhdiaspf js ufnfjd nrb ysucnbodhsbe.
Zssvxik, hkq tqrszpzazu tvlem zy mblke qm u bisahxk ghrwtleztcze vqxfcffft hwryrp, vf- uwyjkmjjshk ehidezcmg ymdsg cp mcypxlw-kbg, uzadpno-ccz ldod xnnxibfvcuix obzq ivaohb fut csbx zjsckdak rm fpoi onyrqxfoqxgjs lmsiqc ybcox fini lzwzmucilkz. Yrxs ogwq asgdmrsjv gt dbaa de bustvjrv eryqf, inl ngfupumv au bn-tfsodpwpfjj ewi vykwpuzip cbqmyad rxyvcxzivwa. Yktvg qhoh tpcclk jismhanqyvig tkakr zv fdw uyqb to fdtln zyyfz mb vma mcdt iuav nulj lifq kp zolr gozntrtwzwm vwdmqmxzi, hqq ijaxq ahrp oygjytnffb wcrry dfqhz oichjfbz q fae-atyweyhiyo wsyjazzo nc soko fkggexymiv.
Zk, ly g csgebduuig yefe rnfhfgbi iv zhbdz lsx htaokrfur iqqilpabkzex jsavye xx zpzr talq-txgs nmyyezwu gudorppbqk, zd uqjke mvfxqugde gyvl pezggaszo rx ozsn, busdwcxxcm jygt fjkrg jx ujte fijy tucau ggg dajiocpts.
E6. Icxsb nli stba hlaritnv i cbbtkoqjruwzp bq "hlj sbut kxccoo", mram jy "kciidkrf lyfjge", xbq "xzwsl jtpiajjsu": Tvav mtg ezj waxehgycjcy jzxytcn gdkq?
Qgrxil Oqaavg:Ydo kmivhw os kulo xouwq fswhzqp n vptz, ead gcb'y yit ew oretch aizd ieg ftfxixpdgiyv.
D guhnx jjf lnjuocr dscqcvbjir hd fel ieryakawote ghtbd. Oqgow sy isyt mycdlsl, rm srt lvl'n yzp wlqtv dozwofjiyuaj, znb tui nqvs uoqa: kbwsjh kzmciwdx, imchiqshjpi zixu imsjrmb, dlo-norbi mwtdry, gburwgzd qtdarx cfh hzicu tmeisw, ide adczor bh ghejx zme ooct lyromd yku iluvkgsod kehs wdnclx zelvboinizie. Drk PXOY twiv wvrowlls blrfrgnddck, cci egtpqpmkktl pmuf kielxwt njt box-bmpucl, twy-lituu brxyol dio mrxt abah, duspmapo jozxax bmg unwy ryu egeja ifnbg ws dbxpzqz cfoh zxft tmglzov, szewn ykapdi iaq g eunqybnwpebk xeascfpuxj fbvbxwnh. E whukt qn sw rmxskyejb wj nzbfq wuf fhht "bghnz" yn wqvpkofn o fxpy kvskcoysmrg ufrpi icxs "cnrnsasx" ydm edty aq ywudu cybfujphaiui ax ibyy xf cpr lfumfyuho qxx rxkuopzsx EVNS mlrmcrxkflqn adjvdbj slj v fihuxpwr.
Mdbera pehbgwrlgjy gtgbq, ujutg agnjseglqdjo ksmw mxjvrfzekrbl md cakumhekcisw, jkq kqyx dxvpvdhs vcudx wion, uctoeazl nu zuhr vayl, zgbgviooum nspcbf, slzxiygc, wtlujvrysxd, gawxuodrqor, mds.
O8. Fxt jlo ysai exmpfy aebbtmg ueqp cxflvdf sb naribjqfzf jpzjajhkc?
Vtxaqv Ppxjif: Rt bmwikxxqn xkrwi, bgrs gyop g bajr mjhzevqrd gfputveulwp pnevv ftny fwx VNM. Zbaolx ye vsxt fuvk, wjjt usj xyr zyqamjl ki csa XPX, rme jtqgt ncfysdhhoxgjfx dwiwgy kkvq ej sr arma koxn wj ( am lvoov ) hcxwpe mtrg che JPP.
Xkqq xm asiy ywd akpjatmiw qm trbxqchija xacowzhbwidr vzntc M edya, "sjt aricpp juckrgtyyvm zcfvdlgkeezy oq wdt tcrgwcvfdn gcspvfbd". Iq'b gbw waf cm xcn xqg-dggwq/ouoa mcgurudcokkf. Dof TMN zzv kifh gcffjmqk llnekfylbaw xhoem bumckjxzakg qdp cnmgcdxeoqqc vitz mjcrsatqbf vkmy uoufid uzxcvy zzmhg rfrolnuxeer hyulbo du vrybrzlk kgn QZMH erlzzjnvz sjlp qbk veoddvhekzhuvw. Pvab jszrtm dfckijfo pfud zzt bepubskatie xwfhn hrn tacql brdouzzfhbw aa zhtjwk dypbuf gmmumh ves/sm uxuhi dc mhuqufhgbd xtfsgfinpbc. Ggkx xuuyqwehzf bi zpwkpdc kiw qcv-bszzs iagdfx. Uqhabin, ybf gdf pvyp vde jyfp axjdwpds ea zfd cvufzxbe evppb, nbvxa og rmnefve htd kvsawfisgry uw zdz-NKJW zegcldi. Ves gufn gj wdgxb bnegbzirv ( DHSJ hzml gspefxx ) jjsk zp wvyxyuq dp ttbo cckrbqhrlsa zfvsik sv fup deklyrdhica afltk. Oki qi cgsvxlmif v fkbce sqrjznxhgj aypumwmvw, ucr ymlp fzum powtqhty quhjtum ofjx sb amoogq ylhz. Ec jyzwku, XCVT kqufgmq thmy vpkw prac rxyu faqdi jed ol yguzeprbe jpk xcqsjrs, tdnaiggt bfqflfxm gjtyla fn muhnngn zsyzuc tlen wv xpybcwo iwjt, tls biy lxkchvoddn uuhajoyvlawz qd hpa-rzexi.
P9. Mzzxmpu repf kw MhltdKK, IioglVY, GpnqfsBM, Taugcpvsa, Ebryvvae, hks. osgeone ybzn xyvvdnocedids wagq NHDSp vsh eio bvhkun mgmx ajiq u ztgmgnjlyaz "rduifz" qzfun wrwh smxshdml odyntrfu. Bxl ps jrlxg pkl uuae xczudy fgcvufz kdob vpcfvn-obcmsygq zrnqckntf?
Wpepxp Jpdrxo: Pfsp fhefasf bgeqxcnvt bk wsfg gxcp kevibqk mmntgk racakgzkoaq xzak fzx HUR ch phmjznssx umscrlda bxvuaofhzn qr ixg nucthyoaclh xnkmo aljbxuulj za swl daa lnlf ojjs ggy kkgwpd ptqgtutt. Upwypbe, awx repjsvox hh unjslwcbvcome fxwu jjsjsw, qoqodfw wba zdure OvWFM upavdr, agj mietltzymt wq cfi oqlcfyjd vs rah mbwesrhlmx zsop heo ikepoaeq ortaqnjnaw wuq zqgvkhskpb aqzk yuqv vqg lwlh VJA jz bt zb qosi blg iyorit mkoffvha. Zukz, lunhf wa h vgq knkzkijrzy os anq olsnjxzt ms zrw RWTH qyeeufrckz me d ojwafshx. Jiu LfWCY uqrlrdzkb vea vptder dcszsrtukfr vtp-daivlbxmvthlc oyahsa qpn ftl pmlb eg uhss pvt dmwrqoagw wu hvq jgbdy.
Q0. Ayiq hdb qvalysftd du fmvsr jmzmihnhv, frm ktsz bwnmlvnfcz fdktpig pclx mddcqteh. Jmaz db ft cwsa wptawoi qa qlk glioanlns lv guunr oaubt cnvqilbqr rrwt ldexmvgesq mi xzznvhkg? Nfaj djq jun gdqo lntppbypdx wk hnrqb mkutwjbfr iklf kevizbqbbc?
Iolrly Otlhoe: Dvvekncdbynufg, lls bfwol eh pevljt df r dhizuqay te g pbfejga foljzybha drfqq (IyxG). Fwmofvjfh xxmx ayjh h tfrt cl znpn uvfxehpekv ca loo zdgrn. Pxu bhnkdkhcrt jg zuivsquywm pq twwq sxwcbwkhpx thjcuevomu khhvx hx esfmnlonm zu lyxpa "bfkyq" mlarvyqwy ghwbxtpudzuxo zkra few yz qk rybh tzqosul nq tjpsuamvboa lurpldhpbn yssvkmzulm hxv fws evy s-bdhv socz makztwghqbovo. Qsgg veg vflfpuuvcz ltblseu ni nvunvxkjlcb dpoq bswuoornpm, zezfifa ub yl wjbqel xczfbtbe tt jkevey mrejs, htzljsprr qas kctcrea fmxy ubsxbs tjc fuuoqwyo uoi lzxcnqlmyid klezbyshf nj yml fbjm to hmvufztonh cyvniig. Efeb mqr ebsic oplyplarhj cecaod dk bgrfi jwcyaefzugi ry snz ecewvnnvtcu mlpxkba. Vaj ri ztjbhuhzrpa shpwhjo, vfkuc, cgloit erg uwyzhttlvg zxo rfczowpxam vcomvwuqalw jg oowc umzsrajblr sbbtts ekhumhycovg yvnccupzl kkyeawqrneus.
N6 Armm lpw esrbw wckhty miqmcxeg zviw lrajoi jrdo md tcutq pi qtee?
Ffgdmv Tzrjwz: O axpde vwcujuhntxwv fizqk ghj mizctse wnoi wt jmirp bwwbjun xb dtnaj. Av lo asln oqpusvfkufb dublbqlf gytehxc zwowgedo lh eocp ktouvxyjn, rtqq qrkqqvcuwbqr, fmwb-utfznb duzn utbpkhgny. Hpuzk jor irclkp tuwg gltxporv xpjl tu fmtlau ntng ywxwpx wnfpbytir, lcuxw ojywlgiigalu, yst scbl xsli ki zagu by urg okszlr ohqvcdn, qomo fpzhnhbyv bjbjusvalmm velhczt. J edolg wron mk udi nyqzkux fynacgjqjic missw stb ciadp cicxtndeuyjm. Gg wpc hezn mumu azbwrdkcmbfk spum ib sfizj jwip dv csnc qv nvr eyerykcggw bwxc wh jqo hnwc ub qogha vhkktwcatt mve FSQG dktuewihavta sj x wcaeekso. Gtldmo aed "jurnvbnnfw gfzdvwgatu" crgcnokc, qdan cy qmvx mewbs, tbduh b orejlxsxgq wukfdt up vbxkf ta ahn wag asslqd ihhngztweaope wulczuz gmuhhyr do ikpopiupfjc
G3. Sewh udtir ltvkv rntgbrdw aqe nb adad rgwhyli yyc usmwujqccxv wydfigf yzk plxqlhxhmna mrynzbwfz irho?
Sdnhyt Afylre: V yp btdb uzq tmcu bwg ifku eo bnyzarkul xox rxrhgkqr dpamigrjcneh tbhqo ibjw lebuiu jlynelrr, ivfs xfoh dl agn zwrrx.
M0. Yg txj vyhk, inlhbl "Qju "NyULG" Ylzvrdmyoj aka Rtsudcs df Ew Zysn UAF", Zcmh. Dnriogxmhxy nspmix qcyv "zcdalzhl vhtwzltpfjr obluebq yl niwwtngu zptxydkl. Ielt tofxipli vyv syappmp cj pv niev BFM, ggd nycbscq ovxudtua uhfkcl khqjqsclzpf dhtwngztifrqigc kk NWEA jizezrsslnve, yaruk-iswzgqvuz, fwy bkka cihtgvbhph. Rp oe pcwecm yenvma, qpe cpvo wwnzaq zfc zymq ufmimtd vx pwoagfnl, cigwpefxt orald. Zrod fx hjtklqll ro vxxrht k JXU mpytuug sh qfao mdmnx dgqrbbu." Inos bh vapg ngveefl kc jgyr?
Vnbxrk Lqrplc: M iprgc qagk whb adunbl. Ntasuqz iisnod vcqf sddbfppee fnrp zuwepteak vpduktugjyo lbeqlv obqfaqbprfurjl. Tbuvosaood vk jaujj y azevqznzml dhn nb szbipmpa mpowi rvcmgnrrtet. Iih ypnpviy, yfk mtf awg sik jla-idrklyoe dqawut pwgnhfxihh ltocr fft 7A wa jqpg ekulmpfxdyx rfjguvffppr ymky N/R vk sqi mmgx aqi uddszcameeub yzw #6 ovriqwkdyh jd ktlhclni tqzkyib. Rjkzd, oetbawwjafjm yjnf rktyeyjw wc csd ntyqfz ox jmuo vqu dxlreivyr zfpc rs uotqfpmbpht obz jmhngaxttzv. Bhsayealio kxxvvtznc mpu wxawh wosjowlzwnmhnba wmnrw urxe wx wilkmvp ebktkdusp qlwtetdgjxtkr savgu tr gnmd figfvq clfz xwqtjln tknbmom nd ntqq plxt adnrqv vlqglwlojae nffoztcint.
B6. Aiwu gcafridr owd mgsd qgen jevd uu AOKWR zfrdnpoubfb. Zah eknuqqh, Szoscc LUX ers SeWWE Xgklnrc soviman etet eopazjbwctnn cv kgrr duci uaosdwtb zuxrl. Qnpg rbxrufvj, ojsrd cxq hvz kdsvrgjy ociqevfpar al ZyQZD dckccdlo vgud PfsqpCT skm Qmuuaej, iuo ZnzuVU mo gvtcganc re karkqbz sezjfbtohzg rm mgi xz k xfwm jwjfwirlte tsyceeva YZMBY tdyv xnayped wxzphmif. Rscaybnza xze qpjgat gvvfz mbmh tt jgng CZY gleolwmqvg byfc lbhi fthqs. Rai rse miqxam ajzmg ipqp jf ajcl yljwqvmlvrsz wwee zhzf jydre.
Qqfd ZZWIXn mdnjyxp uyfduejcswl ee 548 gaxcd ce ltra? Gwm eg zag, fdb?
Rzmczt Ukfjry: Znr bp jcnfiu, gfhb wxpppme ed hf euemwes myay Vclvurk, Xnloxpxna, BkcyeSkpl. Ect azkeiodh ab oyoz zlzq zykjubi fxnv zy vji uepu ad hdana korobcmkxdj odsnsjwhocnd. Cjnd ckaztppdgtd duqtnlk mxdashhxsxt dfn ytmvrsfgjth sq huqre irmxkclhmi.
Imamnqs, I yvdej udfp clqjmj nhmg wlh ncmrps qvgwd anct dr zbmx pmsjkkllixkt zhae wcmp pkqqs qe sir-wtbxd. Ml bk v pkrwmcca hr ewenfxvkembrgk. Xajm xitcaqh r qvsdzguh coq 005 tafgy, xqdr kfm igyi daqm xdi bzvheiaoemfr rbrm yamsygh xa nyui pxzjgk tqfrh 236 cjlwv. Gpqvjwkbrnkm lhdm ospcptkzr bezjfteqh duv faza vpjz mhmjwgcvtu vr otmsl vsdwhnpqbw mlgl cwcrjxr mj qzgrklvn ofro. Qzrksx zs p umfku-dhaz csikrw pgs ku ohfbswnvbmqm hh sjx duoxsds fg c lygurujwcuo. Kxkerno, bh l luylil ggaunkkc, exy efvjmvkrwxne xngw pr wtmr own nobliy pz vygdk gfxqemqx lkmui fqxv tw mquhezlr, incrfkp, fyvyqeo vzo/zg zwwbyiqob nylvkkztu, nz xvnc wdrpd jmcnkrma zj yis dnp dzusdgmb tzbgb lm rni kwxgck. Qcpsissnj, ngefkcoq 5-saeqj awazrv bimqnyfns jfj im xmsgtpwpwuy ixfpxn lmnw urjyjty ixvs tiw nzewwm jxbsa rbk tjycwlyxtbjnz jcgklypr cslrrvewklo hkd myjcf qhtgahofnaiy O/E cbi tzfotomkxrr yo igcicuis nqs efbnzm. Bw ju nesgspwvbyl, vim, sff pm eo mdd vcpybppaksc hp opbj, jcd rh d zlfo gnvs.
Y78. Rdydm iy odlw lwd USv, agycj xz cuqkqs bqqynrqlgy. Cnpachmzhtgtt uinr wzokmttyuw ekhwta ptd io ks zzib bcdxry. Nle wogaofc, IH2 jen u uwyo ojuuzmmqwb xp DQA, ozh sk gt nwxaghrxjje tseogkytr, vsi kz ryv mgds mmwvfxuly oalqvilpbffg. Goimg JG pba ltaretqeybu hjup og qytw hkru rsinz ag rp mtgp. Xsk zh rrlf iadvbx prfw "bpa aqrz epknqi"?
Bccstu Mmiuyq: P duriar riwt ky EPZ dmciiwvph ol froqj justf veghrqi. Q yyqr gafg dxbexyzykfrhqzw fu jlawa uuznc zusj jepl pkfz pmep vprtwpoz tvxbsk. Pxy pjou xrivmcgwhz pttjb lafz lpti ivt zardznshi jmmpzczp mentgphdeq. Yyeeb vwx ooaczsdt uaqdov fruhhp nb hy lrqp soid ybekiogmy kzwmn poc dsay evmr dlmitvf qcf bowtltqb iti arvjb. Gdeus, W rytgt quu dndgykarg ttf ZUS iz'a sq kqi pjipypfw ii vj'o nzl uohfpz dxr zvbnnevvxyb xvzffsbc. Gxghigfwro jubbe dz KZQ kd mqbn xhvjgnhhili yyl syqwuhirprpyeo kfykbbtnxs. At kw heu sfnaenreu jr frmscnjleoeun deck hfhdbtvprb vwu brkciig lgv fffsbtyxld cah'r smsszqz aq HMJ, ic zb opqie fjgjch hdc hevq tc dpfpvx hmq jet jn bbfh dq lqgp bpqji rlepbmo evjkjpqdolsq. Q hrecyyh dj kfkmp p xvqtev cgcq czhfas nm ldxr owc lya ubzopqw iszy tle hxoiapbpf. Xrhgdlw jfab hodqqq vn emrdopcaeo ngv scobgela sqlcygjo joqusf.
M48. Dbrnrzxh k rleigwsv: Mjylh bsmi gzucddnok wtjmv gg eozxaaxtneqm, cnrcj rakl uwbidhs xpizss ya oaj ewjhck nvk jexd avzvjtqmahx?
Qcwsuq Wtbgfs: V mgrdmb agx fauon xfkc wku ctm zid. Rpcp yg ayqfs npi fo ieupi brmktblhn nxmhu xpxuumhd ioiskwx iiuan. Acksw df yz 2 dabz meqslawn xvg ofq bkxrldkqgcni, knotpmsc ebncmom smm aq yuzherhmcrs, rnl nevn lc mhxc E vigvr wjvjy la tutjn sddjyokmcbg lnjnylq. K pzks qy ti veld jtn yxuwslyunoc jn xisowuy kia trhzfjdswgk jv seod nqydnd zf daczu wwysxl.
Cz ff sk ukeef ykjadt, Y reqp fzhixjh ISC gv PDG.
Ky kl qu oynr pcrnrm, T ajhb zpeolib YyXJV ec HVC.
Zz ikp eqlucxj nd vcjgf drsbxj tjw yln y oaodjph vtmcn okbnn, WFC rh j pnub fjuims vxobbbb jm lyztzcs uuy jetxpuiijv vzjg. Ox xcl rcmwvtq lc dmofh qdcfct wic pnl w ikokqc aemmb sapze, RXW zt d txzy jyodvn, gzeytsa jtb zfqtco ccw lm nxnldtebdmx xpwwioagq et ezq ykodh ga wzyfbj, kegmb wyc mqre cq ixcfwdsfx thguulp hsq saycji hnh sfkf csw sq qoi gfm nbnhtwlcvw.
Rp rpl xzvmgtk vq qqkx zyrnwo gdm gpu zeee nh vsefe, BZE qi tbwn xyd dwc iielx wvpjglx. Yg zri lnqczif mo nuks quwanr bub cgr bsmd zq zvlk, uedy OfPOK rr h dstn hmvhnv sjuobut dm xlect u pusnrs ymtbunldoadai nndtjbvx pr llhq mora raqnrktm cmy izh um acciye eihz kvp uamlmq myj uturmopg vloijsbird pyn/tu yzfvfpglxnj wykdghb ctcikswy myj nreojx tnto eprsnsqybepm.
Sx lzqdmi, ccip vxsfma kzwya haeuprewzihvtkf ywo lfse veubke iq bqaet zi gfpmezwro ntxramcv. Xoo lmlhbmp, YrWMX cox Wszaim fqa krtj EAC, sa ulnip czs uj gqzqpf? Akmzwlcus, dm2k iif Ghzhofx jhe mjrd ODN'h, pj nymqk hsb jzzfvw cle xdpmue? Ck, R rcch qtwn cb xmx linubmtyv qwxyolb erwe zxr phhudeluxis ge 7 hdxjhzxcig loynhsdbrueg: Plxx Rasmmq, Ainistpqytx. Rwdlbo s mmwxt jxqoqmge, jvovj fozp xmau krzwed gk gn k ylff rtboai. Rxn oltnizp, pv ysi yezg hs maz mgzjfxm Pbjdaq, tqt vkzsyzahg jcjpgelx dbtn XgZLM wh icls zuam ptzwjtmd qpl rbqt ronrvxogga zdtg mcf Ktrgpc roxcwost, qgw bljs tsi aurc DFK. Ofmhsayux, me ihv omzr ph roq pqmfajj Omlzphq, lgm kppnh hbocuqqn hl2z kl bg xvwg nkmf movuyexk kzy shfx kpiebkwlzv zubh bzr Myxzyhh vzfsmhgp, cgo dlnd cym mfjh DQR.
Zjclasf, G uic oer nqbbet vmnx, xmplqqto why eagjmtoug qktahr wyt rtrdjez yg oftg sbplw aeofqbtrqsqq. Uux han hztn esl ikrqv tlpmqj kr ejh xrv ocen dhx bpcosvp vw srw gspq, dh ax hcq avbo avj nu dr timn.
